Buffalo Nickels

Buffalo Nickels

Buffalo Nickels

Are you a coin collector looking for buffalo nickels? Look no further than Arnold Jewelers! We have great deals on nickel coins and offer fair prices when you sell them.

Our Buffalo Nickels are the real deal; they were struck by the United States Mint between 1913 and 1938 and make perfect collectibles! You can trust that our coins are of superior quality and authenticity, so add an amazing piece to your collection today!

What year is a Buffalo Nickel worth money?

The most valuable nickels are 1937-D –Three Legs, 1935 Doubled Die Reverse, 1924-S Nickel. The condition of the coin matters greatly. While a mint coin could land some serious cash in your pocket, a coin of the same year in worse condition might only be valued at .50cents. 
A special reminder that coins should never be cleaned. Collectors and dealers can tell when they are cleaned up, and the value plummets drastically.

What is so special about a Buffalo Nickel?

In 1912, the U.S five-cent piece underwent a radical transformation as renowned sculptor James Earle Fraser sought to beautify American coinage with his Nickel design. This iconic silver creation featured an ultra-realistic portrait of a Native American on one side and an image of buffalo – standing proudly against its open prairie backdrop – on the other; both images honoring America’s proud western heritage in stunning detail.
Not only do we have genuine buffalo nickels for your collection, but we also offer a wide range of additional coins from all around the world. Buy confidently at Arnold Jewelers and experience the best in service, selection, and value.
Looking to sell your coin collection? We buy U.S. and ancient Coins from all over the world. Visit our Sell Your Coins Section for more information!