Coin Shops in Tampa Florida: Why Arnold Jewelers is Your Trusted Local Numismatist

If you’re searching for the best coin shops in Tampa, Florida, look no further than Arnold Jewelers in nearby Largo, FL. For over 40 years, our family-owned business has been a trusted destination for coin collectors, investors, and those looking to sell rare U.S. coins. With a team of experienced numismatists and a reputation built on knowledge, integrity, and fair pricing, we proudly serve the entire Tampa Bay area, including St. Petersburg, Clearwater, and Largo.

40 Years of Numismatic Expertise

Arnold Jewelers has been in business since 1984, making us one of the longest-standing coin buyers and sellers in the region. Our lead numismatist, Zack Arnold, has decades of hands-on experience evaluating, grading, and appraising U.S. and foreign coins. Over the years, we’ve helped thousands of collectors build portfolios and assisted families in selling inherited coin collections for top dollar.

When you walk into our shop, you’re not just another customer—you’re part of our extended family. That’s the Arnold Jewelers difference.

Popular U.S. Coins We Buy and Sell

At Arnold Jewelers, we specialize in both collectible coins and bullion. Some of the most sought-after U.S. coins we buy and sell include:

• Morgan Silver Dollars (1878–1921) – Iconic and highly collectible, especially in higher grades or rare mint marks.

• Peace Silver Dollars (1921–1935) – Striking design that represents America’s post-war optimism.

• American Silver Eagles – One of the most popular bullion coins in the world, containing one troy ounce of .999 fine silver.

• American Gold Eagles – Trusted by investors, these bullion coins are backed by the U.S. Mint.

• U.S. “Junk Silver” Coins – Dimes, quarters, and half dollars containing 90% silver.

• Buffalo Nickels & Indian Head Pennies – Beloved among collectors for their history and artistry.

Whether you’re a new collector, a seasoned investor, or someone liquidating an estate, we can help you evaluate and sell your coins at competitive prices.

Atocha & Shipwreck Coins

Few collectibles capture history and adventure like Atocha and shipwreck coins. These treasures, recovered from sunken Spanish galleons such as the legendary Nuestra Señora de Atocha (wrecked off the Florida Keys in 1622), are highly prized by collectors. Each coin carries a tangible link to the age of exploration, piracy, and transatlantic trade, making them not just valuable but truly historic. At Arnold Jewelers, we proudly buy and sell authentic shipwreck coins, giving Tampa Bay collectors a rare opportunity to own a piece of maritime history.

Gold & Silver Coins

Whether you’re a serious investor or a new collector, gold and silver coins remain among the most reliable and sought-after forms of wealth preservation. From American Gold Eagles and Buffalo Gold Coins to Silver Eagles and pre-1965 “junk silver” U.S. coins, these bullion pieces are trusted worldwide. Gold and silver coins offer both intrinsic value and collectibility, making them a smart choice for those looking to diversify their portfolio.

At Arnold Jewelers in Largo, Florida, we buy and sell a wide range of bullion coins and help customers understand the market trends that affect their value.

World & Ancient Coins

If your interests extend beyond the U.S., you’ll love our selection of world and ancient coins. From ancient Roman and Greek coinage to medieval European issues and modern foreign mint bullion, these pieces tell the story of civilizations across time. Collecting world and ancient coins allows you to hold history in your hands—whether it’s a Roman denarius, a British sovereign, or a Mexican silver Libertad. Our numismatists at Arnold Jewelers specialize in evaluating and purchasing these coins, giving Tampa Bay collectors a trusted local source for global treasures.

Local Reputation in Tampa Bay

When people search for coin shops in Tampa, Florida, they want a place that’s reputable, transparent, and experienced. That’s why Arnold Jewelers is a top choice for locals in:

• Tampa – A quick drive from downtown for coin collectors and sellers.

• St. Petersburg – Trusted by collectors who want knowledgeable evaluations and fair offers.

• Clearwater & Largo – Our shop is conveniently located right here in Largo, making us central to all of Tampa Bay.

Our reputation is backed by hundreds of 5-star reviews, highlighting our honesty, fair pricing, and deep numismatic knowledge.

Why Choose Arnold Jewelers for Coins in Tampa Bay?

• Fair Appraisals – We evaluate coins carefully based on market trends and collector demand.

• Competitive Pricing – Get top dollar when selling your coins, or shop our selection for fair collector prices.

• Decades of Experience – 40+ years in the jewelry and coin business means you’re dealing with trusted experts.

• Family-Owned & Local – Supporting Arnold Jewelers means supporting a long-standing family business in the Tampa Bay community.

Final Thoughts

If you’re asking yourself, “What are the best coin shops in Tampa Florida?”, the answer is simple: Arnold Jewelers in Largo. From rare U.S. coins like Morgan and Peace dollars to Atocha shipwreck treasures, bullion coins, and world and ancient coins, we’re your local source for buying, selling, and appraising coins.

📍 Visit our Largo showroom today or explore our online inventory to start your numismatic journey with trusted experts.